MedAu Clinical
Clinical
Domestic Violence and the GP
Samiro Douglas





MedAu

Resources

Columns

Computing

*gr clinicalbar

Aboriginal Health

Adolescent Medicine

Anaesthetics

Complementary Medicine

Dermatology

Drugs and Alcohol

Emergency

ENT

Geriatrics

Health

ICU

Internal Medicine

Musculoskeletal

Paediatrics

Palliative Care

Sexual Health

Surgery

Women's Health

Psychiatry

Taking Depression Seriously

Medicalising Suffering

The Heart of Parenting (Book review)

Domestic Violence and the GP

Gambling Addiction

Children Disclosing Sexual Abuse

What Predicts Divorce?

Adult Sequelae of Child Sexual Abuse

Suicide

Rape Trauma Syndrome


Search



About MedAu
Table of Contents

Domestic Violence and the GP

Last Modified 1/12/98

Six reasons why domestic violence is a GP's problem:

  1. Domestic abuse is one of the most common forms of assault in our society.
  2. Domestic violence is not just physical assault.
  3. Victims of domestic violence say the emotional abuse is the most devastating.
  4. Physical bruises heal, but emotional abuse destroys the very essence of an individual.
  5. It occurs across all levels of society and is not easy to pick unless you ask. Domestic abuse results in a range of significant health problems other than acute injury.
  6. Victims of domestic abuse are more likely to attend a doctor's surgery for treatment of complaints such as anxiety, depression, pelvic pain, sexual and gynaecological problems, not coping. Or, for problems with children such as bed wetting, anxiety, behaviour problems at school.

Diagnosis

According to the results of research conducted by Mazza, D et al (1996) throughout 15 general practices in metropolitan Melbourne, doctors are not skilled in diagnosing domestic abuse.
  • doctors diagnose only one battered woman in 25; and
  • only 27% of women disclosed the abuse to their doctor.

Why don't doctors ask and why don't women tell?

  • Doctor's don't ask because they don't think about it.
  • Women don't tell because they are ashamed, scared or don't think it's relevant.
  • everyone fails to recognise domestic abuse unless the physical violence is present.

Asking about violence and abuse

Many health professionals feel overwhelmed and uncomfortable when faced with the prospect of asking a question about domestic abuse. It is important to ask direct questions such as:
  • Are you afraid of your partner?
  • Does your partner behave in ways that frighten you sometimes?
  • Is there a history of domestic abuse?
  • Have you ever been pushed or shoved?
  • Does your partner sometimes yell so much that it frightens you or the children?
Another approach could be something like this:
  • Frequently women with these symptoms are having difficulties in their relationship. Are you sometimes frightened of your partner?
  • Many women who experience anxiety/depression talk to me about violence and abuse in their relationship. Is anything like this happening for you?
Don't be put off if a woman tells you she hasn't been hit, or it only happened once. Physical abuse is only one tactic of abuse. explain that hitting, punching and shoving are only one of the tactics of abuse. Other tactics such as put downs, yelling, threatening behaviour, unreasonable jealousy, threatening to report you to welfare, denying you access to money or the car, or any behaviour that attempts to create fear or control your life is also a tactic of domestic abuse.

Don't be concerned if a woman denies the abuse. Maybe she'll feel safe enough to talk to you about it on her next visit. Always ask when you are alone with your patient. Never ask in front of a partner

Other relevant statistics

  • In Australia violence occurs between one in three and one in ten families
  • One in five patients at the Royal Brisbane Hospital emergency department were victims of domestic violence (Roberts GL et al 1993 'Domestic Violence & Health Professionals')
  • In 20% of women who have experienced domestic abuse, the violence occurred for the first time during pregnancy. (Australian Bureau of Statistics ëWomen's Safety Australia' 1996)
  • 38% of women had experienced one or more than one incident of violence since the age of 15 years. (Australian Bureau of Statistics ëWomen's Safety Australia' 1996)
  • 19% of women aged 18-24 has experienced an incident of violence in the previous 12 month period. (Australian Bureau of Statistics ëWomen's Safety Australia' 1996)
  • Up to 80% of homicides in Australia take place between those familiar to each other (Wallace, A Homicide: The Social Reality. NSW Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research 1986)
  • In 95%-98% of reported cases the perpetrators are men and the victims are women (NSW Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research 1984-1987)
  • Closer to home, domestic abuse constitutes a significant percentage of operational police work in the Northern Region local command.

Samiro Douglas
Domestic Violence Coordinator, NRAHS
SAMIRO@doh.health.nsw.gov.au



Discussion
Domestic Violence and Screening It in the Health care centres
domestic violence.....women talking to their doctors
Domestic Violence and adolescents
Domestic Violence and Suicide

JFree, joy@whwest.org.au
Posted 11/7/2001 1:43 PM


I am looking for research exploring links between domestic violence and suicide.

Your help would be appreciated.

Joy
Women's Health Researcher
Women's Health West



Domestic Violence and Screening It in the Health care centres

, vickit.com.au.
Posted 2/8/2000 6:31 PM


I'm a third year nursing student and I would like
to know if you have any information on the advantages and disavantages on screening women for DV. I would be very greatful if you could send me any articles on these above issue(s).

Thankyou Hope to here from you soon.

Donald




domestic violence.....women talking to their doctors

Karol Osmond, crshawn@adss.on.ca
Posted 8/5/99 12:54 AM


I am an Outreach worker for a Women's shelter in a small northern Ontario community in Canada.
Would you happen to know where I could find some posters relating to domestic violence so that the doctor's clinics in this area may display them (things such as talking to your doctor about domestic violence)?

Thank you,
Karol Osmond



Rhonda Johnson, rhonda742@hotmail.com
Posted 9/6/2001 12:05 AM


I went to my local hospitals on at least two different occasions for a severe beating and could not really tell the truth because my boyfriend at the time had to play like he was really concerned and wanted to stay in the room with me so I would have to lie and say I fell in the shower untill finally he beat me so bad that I almost lost my vision and permantely lost my sense of smell. You don't know how I miss being able to smell something really good cooking or candles burning. Anyway when I drove myself across town because I terrified he would find me and really hurt me i got a hospital and they were so nice and even got security to guard my door while i was being treated. They even asked when my family came if i wanted them to let them come back. I will never forget how compassion and warm they were to me.



Domestic Violence and adolescents

CMathis, Cmathis@EPA.org
Posted 4/2/99 11:26


Do you have any info on web sites pertaining to this topic. The current info for patients,patient services,statistics,pilot programs. Please send to
my email address. Thank You






Please send us your comment
My Name:
My E-mail:
Select from one of the current topics

or Name a new topic
Comment:

Return to top of page

This page was last built on 18/7/2001; 11:32:29 AM.
It was originally posted on 22/1/1999; 7:51:44 PM.
Webmaster:
LemLink

lemlink@medicineau.net.au

The Heart of Parenting (Book review)

Index Gambling Addiction


MedAu MedicineAu