Palliative Care Au
Clinical
An Approach to Pain Management in Palliative Care
Joanne Doran





MedAu

Resources

Columns

Computing

*gr clinicalbar

Aboriginal Health

Adolescent Medicine

Anaesthetics

Complementary Medicine

Dermatology

Drugs and Alcohol

Emergency

ENT

Geriatrics

Health

ICU

Internal Medicine

Musculoskeletal

Paediatrics

Psychiatry

Sexual Health

Surgery

Women's Health

Palliative Care

An Approach to Pain Management in Palliative Care

Fentanyl Patches - Update

Fentanyl Patches

Common Problems with Morphine Use

Dressings for Malignant Wounds

Hypercalcaemia

Ketamine

Lymphoedema - Palliative Physiotherapy

Morphine in Nursing Homes

NSAIDS in Palliative Care

Antidepressants in Palliative Care

Bowel Obstruction in Palliative Care

Secondary Malignancy

Strontium 89

Strontium in Prostate Cancer

Terminal Restlessness


Search



About MedAu
Table of Contents

An Approach to Pain Management in Palliative Care

Last Modified 1/12/99

What is pain

In 1986 The International Association for the Study of Pain defined pain as 'an unpleasant sensory and emotional experience associated with actual or potential tissue damage, or described in terms of such damage'. There are two lessons to learn from this.

  • 1. Pain is an experience. If you have a hangover and feel ill with headache, nausea and vomiting, although an unpleasant experience, you know you will feel better tomorrow as you vow never to drink alcohol again. However, if you have exactly the same symptoms but it is because you have a malignant brain tumour, the experience is very different and much more frightening.
  • 2. Pain is subjective. We know this because the same noxious stimulus can produce vastly different pain behaviours and analgesic requirements in different people.
Leading on from this, an alternative (and more easily remembered) definition is: 'Pain is what the patient says it is.'

For the rest of this article, I will concentrate on pain in cancer patients as that is the most common cause of pain in palliative care patients.

Some useful statistics

  • 1. 30-50% of all cancer patients receiving active therapy experience pain.
  • 2. This increases to 60-90% in patients with advanced disease.
  • 3. 80% of cancer patients have two or more pains.

Causes of pain in cancer patients

  • 1. 70% cancer related.
  • 2. 15% treatment related.
  • 3. 15% incidental.

Thus with all this in mind, what is the best way to approach pain management in palliative care? One approach is the 3-step analgesic ladder recommended by the World Health Organisation, which addresses the severity of pain but not the cause. A more practical model is 'the Stickman' model developed by Professor Lickiss, Sydney Institute of Palliative Medicine.

The benefit of this model is that it addresses the cause of pain as well as dictating a holistic approach to pain management. This is a simple 4-step approach:

Step 1. Reduce the noxious stimulus

Reducing the noxious stimulus means diagnosing and treating appropriately the cause of the pain. This may involve surgery, radiotherapy, chemotherapy and good nursing care.

Case 1

A 35 year old man with advanced SCC of the oropharynx was receiving oral morphine for a painful mouth. Despite escalating doses of morphine, his pain was not controlled and he was very drowsy. Examination of his mouth revealed rampant soft tissue infection. He was started on antibiotics and in less than three days his morphine requirements were halved and he was pain free and alert.

This case highlights the need to treat the cause of the pain, rather than giving morphine as the panacea for palliative care patients.

Step 2. Raise the pain threshold

As we know from the discussion above about the experience of pain, emotional influences on pain perception need to be taken into account with pain assessment. This was best exemplified by soldiers in battle who had horrendous injuries with little perception of pain. It is thought that due to the excitement of the surrounding battle, their bodies produced sufficient endorphins to mediate the pain perception to the point where they may not have even realised they were injured.

The opposite case is generally true of palliative care patients, where anxiety, anger, depression, frustration etc, work to lower the pain threshold and so worsening the pain, which in turn is a reminder of the disease, which in turn worsens the depression and so on.

Often, simply acknowledging the problems and fears the patient has can be enough to give some relief. Occasionally the use of professional support such as social workers, counsellors, pastoral care workers may be required for ongoing support.

However, given that most palliative care patients are in the community, this support will often fall to the GP and community nurses. The downside for the GPs is generally lack of time to deal conclusively with such issues. The upside is that they may have cared for patients and their families for many years and therefore be well aware of and able to tackle psychosocial issues. In this situation, the community nurse can be an invaluable support person for the patient and family.

The use of drugs for emotional issues needs to be considered. Anxiolytics can be of great benefit without the concerns about addiction or tolerance for palliative care patients. Of course depression is a common feature in this patient group and can be quite difficult to diagnose because of crossed symptomology, eg. lack of appetite, low mood, asthenia, morbid thoughts, and so on. The difference between appropriate sadness and depression can be blurred. However, two distinguishing questions to ask are:

  • 1. Are you depressed? Generally, depressed patients will say they are depressed, whereas sad patients will admit being sad, but deny being depressed.
  • 2. Are you the person you used to be? A clinically depressed patient will generally say they are not.

Finally, the easiest way to raise patient threshold for pain is to make sure they are getting a good night's sleep. Having a progressive, incurable illness is a process of having your reserves stripped away. Be they reserves for dealing with pain, tiredness, stress, loss of autonomy, or whatever. Getting back a good night's sleep is often a simple way of restoring some of those reserves. In fact if you don't ask about sleep you have not completed the pain assessment.

Step 3. Consider an opioid

Whilst negotiating steps 1 and 2, adding an analgesic is the next logical step. As there is a library of books on this subject alone, justice cannot be done in this article, therefore it will be discussed in the next issue.

Step 4. Neuropathic pain

Neuropathic pain is seen as a separate entity primarily because it presents differently from other pains and treatment options differ. Again this is a complex subject which will be dealt with in later issues.

In summary, using the Stickman model for pain assessment is holistic, inclusive and likely to keep you out of trouble. In the next article, the nitty gritty of opioid analgesics will be tackled.

Any comments/queries to Dr Joanne Doran - jdoran@nor.com.au Dr Doran is director of the Palliative Care Service, Northern rivers of NSW.



Discussion
Pain care for your particular body
avascular necrosis to the hip socket, and femur
How the Nurses Deal with the people
An Approach to Pain Management in Palliative Care
CHRONIC SUFFER OF CERVICAL DYSTONIA

C. SMITH, PACE2927@MSN.COM
Posted 4/7/2001 2:00 AM


I AM CHRONIC PAIN SUFFER OF CERVICAL DYSTONIA WHICH IS A RARE DISORDER AND SURGERY IS NOT AN OPTION FOR ME I HAVE SEEN 13 DOCTORS! AND WAS ADICCTIED TO MANY MEDS. THEN I FOUND A DOCTOR WHO CLEANED OUT MY BODY AND BUT ME ON OXYCOTIN. AND YES MANY PEOPLE HAVE THIER VIEWS ON THE MED. BUT I AM AND WAS NOT AN ADDICT TO THIS MED. IT WAS TAKEN FROM ME A WEEK AGO AND I WAS TOLD BY MY DOCTOR HE WAS NO LONGER WRITTING THIS PRESCRIPTION OUT! I WAS OUTRAGED BECAUSE I COULD FINALLY HAVE A HALF DECENT LIFE THEN HE TAKES IT FROM ME. AND PUTS ME RIGHT BACK ON TO WHAT I WAS ADICCTED TO WHEN I WENT TO SEE HE. AND NOW WANTS ME TO GO TO A PAIN CLINIC TO GET ON THIS FENTANYL PATCH. AND I HAVE DONE MY RESEARCH ON IT TO. AND TO ME I AM IN WORSE SHAPE AND TROUBLE WHEN I AM TAKING THINGS I WAS ADICCTED TO AND NOW THEY WANT TO PUT ME ON SOMETHING STRONGER!! NOW YOU TELL ME WHO IS MAKING ME A DRUG ADDICT? IN DESPERATE NEED OF HELP! C.SMITH



Pain care for your particular body

Joan Johnson, craftie@subdimension.com
Posted 24/6/2001 4:14 PM


I have chronic spinal degenertive nerve and bone damage,chronic migraines,osteoarthritis, chronic pain and quite a few other problems that makes my case hard to manage.My problem is getting a doctor to understand the full impact of chronic pain.I began my pain treatment in hospital and in the pain clinic and after four years we got it down pat. I then went to P.N.G. for two years and kept up the same regime and everything was fine until I returned to Australia in December last year.Even though I had with me all my medical records from the previous Australian hospital and doctors,including my G.P. for over ten years to me,very willing to talk to any new doctor I chose to see I cannot get a doctor in the Hervey Bay area to listen and try to understand. I had to begin the rounds all over again.I did as I was asked and went to the new pain clinic at the Maryborough Hospital and the doctor there thinks I am too hard for them so I need to go to the Brisbane Hospital.I will do this
Thank you all for taking the time to read my problem and I pray somebody out there has a positive answer for me before I manage to succeed with the suicide because that thought has not left my thinking yet.
Yours faithfully,
Joan Jophnson
craftie@subdimension.com



avascular necrosis to the hip socket, and femur

Russel Ann Champion, russelann2@aol.com
Posted 5/4/2001 4:10 PM


I have suffered from avascular necrosis for 5 yrs. I tryed experiment surgery at Duke that had a 80% susess rate... However, I had to stay in a wheel chair for 6 mos after. The surgery comprized of removing a bone in my calf along with tiny blood vessels and putting the in the femor, attaching the vessels to the other vessels leadin to the necrosis in the hope that it would put blood and life back in the dying bones.. the operation appeared to be going well... however after 4 months after surgery I felt and broke my femor right in the spot where the surgery took place. This destroyed the surgery and future sucess. I have now had 3 surgeries on the same site of the brake on the femor inthe last 3 yrs.. Each time the internal part of the fusion of the leg with a rod and screws would not heal. now I am back in awheel chair which I have spent most of my life in the last 3 yrs.. I am only 52 yrs on and the depression and pain in my necrosis and leg surgery has left me desponde




How the Nurses Deal with the people

Kerri Daly, vistana83@hotmail.com
Posted 9/2/2001 9:54 AM


I am currently writing a report on palliative care. I would like a prespective of a nurse and
the difficulties they face with deal with people;
also when they lose them.Anything else would be great help.

Kerri



An Approach to Pain Management in Palliative Care

Scott Couston, scouston@one.net.au
Posted 28/7/2000 6:10 PM


I am terminally in and in intractable pain.

My condition is managed my oral MS Contin TDS. Despite clinical evidence I feel the MS Contin is only effective for 8 hours max NOT 12.

The addition of a trycyclic is most beneficial to dapen down my anxiety and should be part of ALL palitive care treatment.

By far the MOST helpfull drug is continuious subcutantion infusion of Midazolam which allows removal of my anxiety, seems to have a synergestic effect of the Morphine yet I am fully awake.

The addition of IVI via PCA of Morphine Sulfate dampens down my breakthru pain.

By far the most usfull adjuct is the Midazolam.

I feel all in terminal intractable pain, patients should be offered the addition of Midazolam.







Please send us your comment
My Name:
My E-mail:
Select from one of the current topics

or Name a new topic
Comment:

Return to top of page

This page was last built on 4/7/2001; 7:14:04 AM.
It was originally posted on 28/2/2000; 9:00:18 PM.
Webmaster:
LemLink

lemlink@medicineau.net.au

Terminal Restlessness

Index Fentanyl Patches - Update


MedAu MedicineAu